caoer115/ucc
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests 45 Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity

rounds: a stock seat gets /ccc-work as its prompt's slash command; the acts read ccc-agent list/send too (ruling A16) #42

Open
caoer115 wants to merge 0 commits from agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash into main
pull from: agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
merge into: caoer115:main
Conversation 0 Commits - Files changed -
caoer115 commented 2026-10-17 06:43:05 +00:00
Owner
Copy link

Ruling A16 (leader 21b7d2e1). Stacked on #41 (branch off its head 99b81cd); merging this lands #41 with it.

r271's and r272's stock-seat-acts seats skipped a prose load /ccc-work. r272's then listed and sent through ccc-agent, which the readers did not read, so the row fell to fail although every act landed.

  • Skill load, deterministic: 65 (stock-acts) and 66 (stock-e2e) prompts open with /ccc-work <task>, the way an official-binary user loads it. transcript.py skill-load reads what the binary recorded. Probed on official 2.1.301 TUI on nyc-2:
    • a loaded skill is the <command-name>/ccc-work</command-name> user entry, then an isMeta entry Base directory for this skill: <dir>/ccc-work with the body, and no Skill call;
    • an unknown name leaves only a system Unknown command: /<name>, and the model is never called;
    • a Skill call answered also counts as loaded.
  • Verdict (acts_decide): every act landed and the skill loaded → pass; asked in words and skipped → missed; the slash command loaded nothing → fail.
  • Acts readers: they also read the seat's own live entry of ccc-agent list and the result of ccc-agent send <peer>. A real daemon failure still reads fail.

Gate (~/.local/share/ucc/work/379d2e5a/slash-replay/{replay.sh,replay.out} on devstation; probe transcripts in …/slash-probe/):

  • r270, r271, r272 acts seats: new verdict missed (recorded pass / missed / fail). r272 sees-self now reads yes off ccc-agent list. r270's harness predates the load check, and its seat made no load either.
  • Probe: /ccc-work loaded → pass; a slash entry with no body → fail (noload); an unknown name → unknown: Unknown command: /ccc-nonexistent-xyz.
  • replay-acts.sh on r272's seat: 23 mutations × 4 decisions, all resolve.
  • bash -n on acts.sh, 65, 66, k4.sh; py_compile on transcript.py: ok.
Ruling A16 (leader 21b7d2e1). Stacked on #41 (branch off its head `99b81cd`); merging this lands #41 with it. r271's and r272's `stock-seat-acts` seats skipped a prose `load /ccc-work`. r272's then listed and sent through `ccc-agent`, which the readers did not read, so the row fell to `fail` although every act landed. - **Skill load, deterministic:** 65 (stock-acts) and 66 (stock-e2e) prompts open with `/ccc-work <task>`, the way an official-binary user loads it. `transcript.py skill-load` reads what the binary recorded. Probed on official 2.1.301 TUI on nyc-2: - a loaded skill is the `<command-name>/ccc-work</command-name>` user entry, then an `isMeta` entry `Base directory for this skill: <dir>/ccc-work` with the body, and no Skill call; - an unknown name leaves only a system `Unknown command: /<name>`, and the model is never called; - a Skill call answered also counts as loaded. - **Verdict (`acts_decide`):** every act landed and the skill loaded → pass; asked in words and skipped → missed; the slash command loaded nothing → fail. - **Acts readers:** they also read the seat's own live entry of `ccc-agent list` and the result of `ccc-agent send <peer>`. A real daemon failure still reads fail. Gate (`~/.local/share/ucc/work/379d2e5a/slash-replay/{replay.sh,replay.out}` on devstation; probe transcripts in `…/slash-probe/`): - r270, r271, r272 acts seats: new verdict `missed` (recorded pass / missed / fail). r272 sees-self now reads yes off `ccc-agent list`. r270's harness predates the load check, and its seat made no load either. - Probe: `/ccc-work` loaded → `pass`; a slash entry with no body → `fail` (noload); an unknown name → `unknown: Unknown command: /ccc-nonexistent-xyz`. - `replay-acts.sh` on r272's seat: 23 mutations × 4 decisions, all resolve. - `bash -n` on acts.sh, 65, 66, k4.sh; `py_compile` on transcript.py: ok.
r271 K4 claude-patched W4: the seat answered "The subagent is running in the
background; I'll print its answer when it returns, then
MARK-K4-claude-patched-W4" while its background Agent ran; wait_text matched
the mark in that planned line and k4_kill ended the seat before the W4 put, so
K4-actor/grade/principal read fail on a write that never ran.

k4_wait_act ends a subagent's write (TUI W4, -p W3) when the record exists in
the user's root, or when the subagent's answer is in the seat's transcript:
transcript.py sub-answer reads the Agent call's result (never a background
launch's async_launched notice) or the task-notification naming the call's
tool-use-id. A seat's own write (W1-W3) keeps its mark wait.
r271's and r272's stock-seat-acts seats skipped a prose "load /ccc-work" on the
same binary and model whose r270 seat followed it; r272's then listed and sent
through ccc-agent, which the readers did not read, so the row fell to fail
while every act had landed.

- The skill reaches the seat as the prompt's slash command (65 stock-acts, 66
  stock-e2e), the way an official-binary user loads it. transcript.py
  skill-load reads the load off what the binary recorded: the
  <command-name>/ccc-work</command-name> entry and the isMeta "Base directory
  for this skill: <dir>/ccc-work" body (official 2.1.301, probed on nyc-2), or a
  Skill call answered; an unknown name leaves only "Unknown command: /<name>".
- acts_decide: every act landed and the skill loaded -> pass; asked in words and
  skipped -> missed; the slash command loaded nothing -> fail (the binary's).
- acts_read also reads the seat's own live entry of `ccc-agent list` and the
  result of `ccc-agent send <peer>`; a real daemon failure still reads fail.

Replay: r270, r271, r272 read missed (never pass); the probe's slash load
decides pass, a slash entry with no body fail; replay-acts.sh mutations move no
decision.
This branch is already included in the target branch. There is nothing to merge.
View command line instructions

Checkout

From your project repository, check out a new branch and test the changes.
git fetch -u origin agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash:agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
git switch agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash

Merge

Merge the changes and update on Forgejo.

Warning: The "Autodetect manual merge" setting is not enabled for this repository, you will have to mark this pull request as manually merged afterwards.

git switch main
git merge --no-ff agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
git switch agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
git rebase main
git switch main
git merge --ff-only agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
git switch agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
git rebase main
git switch main
git merge --no-ff agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
git switch main
git merge --squash agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
git switch main
git merge --ff-only agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
git switch main
git merge agent/379d2e5a-stock-skill-slash
git push origin main
Sign in to join this conversation.
Reviewers
No reviewers
Labels
Clear labels
No items
No labels
Milestone
Clear milestone
No items
No milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No items
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
caoer115/ucc!42
No description provided.